Submission – Mashup Map: The London Underground as the New York Subway Map by Sean Sirota

Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Mash-Up Maps

Submitted by Douglas, who says:

I’m sure you would find it interesting, as you have attempted to do the inverse of what Sean is doing.

Transit Maps says:

This map is indeed the exact inverse of my project from 2019 to show the New York Subway in the style of the London Underground diagram, and arguably more successful as it actually works as intended (mine looks great, but is ultimately flawed as it cannot show service patterns).

First things first – Sean has absolutely nailed the New York Subway map style, and perhaps even improved upon it in places – I note with pleasure that all of his station labels are set horizontally, instead of the many varied angles used on the official NYC map.

There’s great attention to detail as well – all of the Tube route line colours have been swapped out with their closest MTA equivalents, meaning the Metropolitan Line has the 7’s purple instead of its traditional burgundy (strangely officially called “Corporate Magenta”). Similarly, all the deep tube lines get letters for route designations, while the shallower cut-and-cover lines get numbers – which emulates the letter/number distinction between the old divisions of the New York Subway.

A couple of minor things: I like to change the background colour in insets just a little bit to help differentiate them from the main map: just a little lighter or darker can work wonders. Also, I see that Sean is selling prints of this map… so he might want to reconsider that Underground Roundel in the bottom right, as TfL are known to come down hard on any unauthorised use of it.

One final thing to note is that this map (as awesome as it is) really emphasises just how amazingly compact and space-efficient the Tube Diagram is – it fits legibly onto tiny Journey Planners, while this map seems to need at least an 11″ x 17″ canvas to work.

Our final word: One of the best style mash-ups I’ve seen: technically excellent, well-researched and actually really informative. Wonderful!

Source: r/nycrail on Reddit

Leave a Comment