Submission – Future Official Map: Denver RTD Rail Map for 2016

June 18, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Future Maps, Official Maps
Tags:

Submitted by Steve Boland, who says:

Cameron, as long as you’re talking about the new Salt Lake City map, I thought you should know that Denver has just adopted a new, updated but unfortunately only slightly amended version of their map, which of course was/is nearly as comically awful as Salt Lake’s old map. I wish it were possible to shame them into shape.

Transit Maps says:

Oh dear. 

Denver’s map has never been as utterly bad as Salt Lake City’s previous efforts, but it’s also been curiously unwilling to change and adapt to the massive expansion that is has been undergoing in the last few years. A map style that was fairly compact and usable – if not that well drawn – when there were only five light rail lines heading south of the city (October 2011, 2 stars) has become incredibly unwieldy and spread out with the proliferation of new rail lines to all compass points under the FasTracks program. What once somewhat worked clearly no longer does.

The main problem with this map is the insistence on having perfectly circular fare zones with Union Station at the exact centre of the concentric rings. This creates some ridiculous levels of spatial distortion, especially on the new B and G lines to the north and northwest of Union Station. If concentric circles are a requirement, I’d suggest that a centre based on the radius of the loop around the western edge of the city would be a better starting point – it would certainly reduce the distance the B and G lines have to travel before reaching the edge of Zone 1!

I personally find the need to show the R Line’s quick little detour off I-225 to the Aurora Metro Center station completely unnecessary in a diagram like this, while downtown is a complete mess with the addition of the second MetroRide shuttle bus down 18th. Not only is the colour used for it very similar to the Green Line, but it also interferes with the directional arrows on the downtown light rail lines.

Our rating: A design that hasn’t moved with the times or the rapid expansion of Denver’s rail network, this map seems to be a slave to the decision to force the route lines (arguably the most important information) to conform to its concentric zone rings (secondary information) – not a great design choice. Getting worse, unfortunately. One-and-a-half stars.

Source: RTD website – link no longer active

New Official Map: UTA Rail Services, Salt Lake City, 2015

June 17, 2015
comment 1
Filed Under:
Official Maps
Tags:

Sent my way by Mike Christensen.

Long-time readers of Transit Maps will know that I have long deplored the abysmal quality of the UTA’s rail services map. I first reviewed it way back in July 2012 (where I awarded it one measly star), and things have only gone downhill from there. 

By April 2013, I was calling it “the most embarrassing transit map in the U.S.” and gave it a big, fat ZERO. I basically pleaded for anyone to make a better map, and showcased a whole slew of alternative maps that actually were.

Now, finally – finally! – the UTA has done something about it, unveiling this new schematic diagram on their website recently. It’s a solid, workmanlike effort – not fantastic by any means, but still infinitely better than the dross that preceded it.

The typeface used is Hoefler & Co.’s Whitney Condensed, a definite step up from Arial! I imagine that a condensed typeface was used to allow the labels for the Planetarium and Old GreekTown stations to fit into their limited space. This works well enough, but does make the rest of the map seem oddly empty. Almost as if to compensate, the designer has put in an enormous north pointer, which at least looks nice. I do think the grey locality labels could be a little larger: they’re only just bigger than the station labels!

The placement of the parking icons is a little odd: it seems like a decision was made to put them on the opposite side of the route line from the label… except when there’s no room to do so, which just makes the placement look a little random. I also would have liked to see a better visual distinction between the two different parking icons than just colour. A “P+” icon for multi-day parking could work well, for example.

Our rating: By no means world-class, but so much better than before. Three stars for making the switch to a better approach!

Source: UTA website

Historical Map: Polish Airlines LOT Route Map, 1939

June 16, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Historical Maps
Tags:

An absolutely phenomenal airline route diagram from 1939, which is both map and schedule in one. 

The thicker route lines represent the routes that belong to Polish Airlines LOT – one of the oldest continually operating airlines in Europe; they still use the beautiful flying crane logo today – with thinner route lines representing partner or connecting airlines. Red lines show daily service, black lines show weekday or irregular service. The departure and arrival times for each flight are indicated within the circles at each city – for the most part, the bigger the circle, the more flights serve it, although Warsaw’s importance is overstated somewhat as LOT’s main hub. Red times show the different schedules for Sundays. The flight/route number for each flight is superimposed over each route line: you can see that some flights “hop” from city to city along the way.

Ominously, a legend at the bottom states: “The services on all lines passing through PRAHA (Prague) are suspended until a special notice is given.” Czechoslovakia had, by this time, been occupied by Nazi Germany, and WWII was about to break over Europe like a wave.

Our rating: Information-rich and weirdly beautiful in a very abstract way. I love this so much: five stars!

Source: histmag.org (in Polish)

Submission – NEW Official Transportation Map of Szeged, Hungary, 2015

June 14, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Official Maps
Tags:

Submitted by barnade, who says:

Two years ago, you reviewed the transit map of Szeged, Hungary (September 2013, 0.5 stars). The conclusion was the map is a mess, as we here in Szeged thought so. Also, you’ve been pointed out that it would be much better, if a circular schematic form had been applied, based on the town’s triple-boulevard structure. Now, the day has come, the new official transit map of Szeged have been applied on trams, trolleybuses and buses, thanks to electric public transport company SZKT and the new local bus and coach provider DAKK. Besides of the foregoing circular scheme, it’s also a new thing to have every line (bus, trolleybus, tram) on a single map. There is another version of the new map, which is based on the real map of the town, with natural scale, having the main sightseeing points on it [the second image above – Cam]. This version can be found on SZKT’s website, and will be placed in the stops.

Transit Maps says:

Wow, what a difference a few years can make! This is so much better than the previous map I reviewed (which, sadly, is still hanging around on the SZKT website). The circular diagram is a natural fit for the city’s shape – as shown by a comparison with the geographical map above – and it’s implemented quite well, with a nice hierarchy from trams (thick yellow lines), through trolleybuses (thinner red/magenta lines) and down to the downtown and suburban bus lines (dark blue and light blue lines, respectively). And I love that the same style of mapping and hierarchy has been carried across between the two different maps – visual continuity that can only help the end user to understand and navigate the system.

The excellent work of the diagram itself is let down a little bit by the typography and placement of the legends, which aren’t quite up to the same standard. This is a pretty minor point, though.

Our rating: Much better! The diagram by itself is nice enough, but it’s in combination with the geographical map that the new mapping system really shines. Probably one of my favourite Eastern European maps now. Three-and-a-half stars.

Source: dakk.hu website (PDF)

Reader Question: Are there any resources available for exporting city map data to vector format for importing into Illustrator?

June 14, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Questions
Tags:

Question: Are there any resources available for exporting city map data (similar to Google Maps, etc) to vector format for importing into Illustrator? Do you utilize any pre-existing data for your projects, or do you simple start from scratch? I’m thinking of your Dallas streetcar map in particular.

Answer: To be honest, most of the time, I just start from scratch. My very low-tech workflow is to quickly grab some screenshots from Google Maps or similar and just start drawing on top of it in Illustrator. I figure that if I’ve drawn it myself, I’ll get a map that does exactly what I want it to do, and I’ll set it up right so that I can edit it easily in the future. It also means that I can simplify things as I work, like straightening out roads a bit for clarity.

I actually do have a copy of ArcMap at work and I can use it well enough to find data, make and export a basic unstyled map for further editing in Illustrator, but most of the time I just end up horrified by the poor quality of paths that it creates – millions of points, unconnected line segments, and so on. Basically, clean up of these files can take longer than just drawing a simple base map myself. For an idea, it only took me 7-8 hours to draw the underlying roads, waterways and parks for the McKinney Avenue Streetcar map, and that included all the fiddly freeway interchanges!

To the other part of your question: I don’t think it’s permissible under Google Maps’ license agreement to export their data for reuse, and I’m not even sure that it’s possible to get vector output from Google Maps.

That leaves GIS (either paid ArcGIS, or freeware like QGIS – but as I say above, results can be less than impressive), or – perhaps more promisingly – exporting as SVG or PDF from OpenStreetMap.org, which has the added bonus of being completely open-source.

Their Wiki has some basic information here, and this seems to be a great walkthrough on getting quality, layered, unstyled SVG exports from OSM using a command-line utility, Maperative.

Note: Unstyled exports are important, because most of the time you want to bring an SVG into Illustrator to apply your own styling. Not having to remove or edit previously existing styles is a huge time-saver!

I hope that this at least starts you on your way! I feel sure some of my readers know far more about this subject than me, so please leave a comment if you think you can shed some more light on the topic.

Submission – Official Map: Bike Network Map of Houten, The Netherlands

June 13, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Official Maps
Tags:

Submitted by Bertram Bourdrez, who says:

I ran into this while reading about Houten (the Netherlands), a town celebrated for its high cycling rate (about 52% of all journeys):

Translation of the first paragraph: 

“Houten is a true cycling town, but all of its red cycleways look alike. Not everyone knows how to find their way around the different neighbourhoods. To solve this problem, the town council and the local chapter of the Dutch Cyclists’ Union have created a wayfinding system, based on a transit map.”

I actually quite like the map, for the gimmick that it is. It has very few of the inexplicable inconsistencies that tend to plague transit maps made for non-transit uses. Apparently they’ve marked lampposts along each route with coloured and numbered indicators to show what “line” you’re on.

On a transit-related note, the main destinations in a Dutch sleeper town like this would definitely be the train stations, which are at the core of the network and easily reached by routes 1, 4, 6 and 7. Both stations have extensive free and guarded bike parking for easy interchange.

Transit Maps says:

First off, Houten looks like an amazing place to get around by bike – cycle paths that are largely separated from roads, a very clear differentiation between arterial and local streets, low local speed limits, and curving streets to effectively deter speeding. It all adds up to that amazing 52% bicycle journey rate that Bertram quotes above. By comparison, my city of Portland, Oregon – often held up as a leader in cycling here in the US – has a bike commute rate of just 6%.

The map itself works well for a couple of reasons. First, it doesn’t overdo the “transit map” concept, remaining true to the actual layout of the city, albeit in a nicely simplified form. Secondly, the numbered routes actually seem to cross the city in a useful, logical manner, rather than just being created in an effort to push the transit map metaphor (something I’ve seen other bike and walking maps do, overcomplicating things to make the map look more impressive).

I also quite like the logo for the network, which has a stylised bike made out of “route lines”. Its rear wheel looks like an interchange symbol from the map, and sits at the intersection of a Blue Line and a Green Line. On the map, these lines (routes 1 and 4) intersect at the main train system: the heart of the city and the network.

Our rating: Simple is better sometimes! Three stars.

Source: Municipality of Houten website

Illustration/Map: Sugar House District, Salt Lake City by Valerie Jar

June 11, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Miscellany
Tags:

Sweet little illustration of SLC’s Sugar House District, including prominent landmarks, lots of parks, bus routes through the area and the new S-Line Streetcar!

Source: Valerie Jar’s portfolio website – link no longer active

Historical Map: Cutaway View of Berlin’s Hermannplatz U-Bahn Station, c. 1929

June 11, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Cutaway Maps, Historical Maps
Tags:

Here’s a lovely cutaway view of Hermannplatz station, at the intersection of what is now U7 (the lower platform here, running east-west) and U8 (the platform above, running north-south). 

The map also shows the pedestrian tunnels that connected the station directly with the basement of the monumental Karstadt department store, then one of the largest in the world. However – probably for reasons of clarity – the diagram places the entrance in the first basement level of the store and shows it as accessible by a bridge across the U7 tracks. In reality, the entrance was in the second (lower) basement level and crossed under the tracks via a tunnel. The Karstadt store was unfortunately blown up by the SS in 1945.

Source: berlin-hermannplatz.de

Visualization: Amtrak Ridership Map for Fortune.com

June 10, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
Unofficial Maps, Visualizations
Tags:

I’m kind of loving this elegantly simple two-colour Amtrak ridership map produced for an article on Fortune.com. It certainly shows the dominance of the Northeast Corridor in terms of ridership! 

Cartographically speaking, I really like the unusual “perspective” projection, which – when combined with some lovely and subtle relief shading – certainly gives the impression of looking down from high above the continent. The labelling of the routes perhaps doesn’t quite live up to the excellence of the mapping, but this is still quality work.

(Although, apparently absolutely no one rode on the San Joaquins spur between Stockton and Sacramento.)

Source: Fortune.com – “Why America is Betting Big on Bullet Trains”

McKinney Avenue Trolley Loop Opens – My Map Updated!

June 5, 2015
Leave a comment
Filed Under:
My Transit Maps, Official Maps
Tags:

The McKinney Avenue Trolley in Dallas, Texas is opening its loop extension tomorrow, June 6th. Working with MATA (the non-profit operator of the trolley line), I updated the map that I donated to them to reflect this new service (see the final map here). 

And – with my permission – DART is also using the artwork on pole signs along the route (shown above), presumably at the locations where where DART and the trolley interchange. Pretty exciting! If any Dallas readers are headed down for the opening festivities, I’d love to see a photo if you spot one in the wild!